Can You Do a Cost Segregation Study After a 1031 Exchange?
TL;DR: Yes, and on most trade-up deals it is worth doing. But depreciation after a 1031 exchange does not work like a straight purchase. The basis in your replacement property splits into two pieces that the tax code treats completely differently, and a study can only accelerate one of them. The money that rolled over from the property you sold keeps the old property's depreciation schedule. The new money you put in on top, called excess basis, counts as property placed in service this year, and that is the piece a cost segregation study can carve into 5, 7 and 15-year components and run 100 percent bonus depreciation against. Trade up with a lot of new cash or debt and a study usually pays. Trade sideways with almost no new money in the deal and there may be very little new to accelerate.
Key Takeaways
- Treasury Regulation 1.168(i)-6 splits your replacement property into exchanged basis, which carried over from what you sold, and excess basis, which is the new money on top.
- Excess basis is new property. Reg. 1.168(i)-6(d)(1)(i): "Any excess basis in the replacement MACRS property is treated as property that is placed in service by the acquiring taxpayer in the year of replacement."
- The carryover piece stays on the old clock. Where the replacement property has the same recovery period and method as the old one, Reg. 1.168(i)-6(c)(2)(ii) depreciates it "over the remaining recovery period."
- Bonus depreciation usually reaches only the excess basis. Reg. 1.168(k)-2(g)(5)(iii)(A): if the replacement property meets the used property acquisition requirements, "only the remaining excess basis for the year of replacement ... is eligible for the additional first year depreciation deduction."
- Building new flips that. Property that meets the original use requirement gets bonus on both pieces.
- The rate is 100 percent. IRS Notice 2026-11 directs taxpayers to substitute "100 percent" for the applicable percentage for qualified property acquired after January 19, 2025.
- There is an election under Reg. 1.168(i)-6(i)(1) to treat the whole basis as placed in service now. It does not make the carryover piece bonus eligible, it restarts the building's 27.5 or 39-year clock, and once made it can be revoked "only with the consent of the Commissioner."
- Rough test: the more new money in the trade, the more a study is worth.
What happens to your depreciation when you 1031 into a new building?
It does not start over. That is the part almost nobody expects.
When you buy a building outright, the whole purchase price gets a fresh depreciation schedule starting the day you place it in service. A 1031 exchange breaks that intuition. Because the exchange defers your gain instead of erasing it, the tax code also carries your old depreciation position forward into the new building. You did not cash out, so you do not get a clean slate.
Treasury Regulation 1.168(i)-6 is where this lives, and it does something simple with two awkward names. It cuts the basis in your replacement property into two parts:
- Exchanged basis. The adjusted basis that rolled over from the property you gave up.
- Excess basis. Everything above that. The reg defines it as "any excess of the basis in the replacement MACRS property, as determined under section 1031(d) ... over the exchanged basis."
In plain terms, excess basis is the new money. Cash you added, debt you took on beyond what you paid off, anything that made the replacement property more expensive than the position you carried into it.
Those two pieces then go in opposite directions, and that is the whole article.
What is excess basis, and why is it the part that matters?
It matters because it is the only part that behaves like a normal purchase.
The regulation treats excess basis as property you placed in service this year, full stop. Reg. 1.168(i)-6(d)(1)(i) says the depreciation on it is figured "by using the applicable recovery period, depreciation method, and convention prescribed under section 168 for the property at the time of replacement."
Read that as permission. Nothing in it says the excess basis has to sit in one lump on a 27.5 or 39-year line. If a component of that new basis is properly 5-year property or 15-year land improvement, it gets that recovery period, because the reg sends you to Section 168 as if you had just bought the thing. Which you effectively did.
That is the opening a cost segregation study walks through. The study is not a tax election or an aggressive position. It is an engineering exercise that determines what the components of a building actually are and how long the code says each one lasts. On a 1031 replacement property, that exercise gets applied to the excess basis, and the result is a chunk of your new money moving off the long schedule and onto short ones.
Because the excess basis is treated as placed in service in the year of replacement, the placed in service date carries the same weight here that it does on any other acquisition. If you are not clear on how that date gets set, we walked through what places a property in service and why it is almost never the closing date.
Why does the carryover piece keep the old schedule?
Because for depreciation purposes, it never stopped being the old building.
Reg. 1.168(i)-6(c) walks through the cases. When the replacement property's recovery period and method match what you were using on the relinquished property, the reg says the exchanged basis "is depreciated over the remaining recovery period (taking into account the applicable convention), and by using the same depreciation method." Residential rental into residential rental, 27.5 into 27.5, is that case. You pick up mid-stream, not at year one.
Trade a rental house into an office building and the periods no longer match. Then Reg. 1.168(i)-6(c)(3)(i) applies, and the exchanged basis is depreciated "as though the replacement MACRS property had originally been placed in service by the acquiring taxpayer in the same taxable year the relinquished MACRS property was placed in service," but over the longer 39-year period. Go the other direction, from a longer period to a shorter one, and Reg. 1.168(i)-6(c)(3)(ii) keeps you on the relinquished property's remaining period instead.
None of those paths lets a study speed up the carryover piece. The recovery period for the exchanged basis is set by comparing the old property to the new one, and a cost segregation study does not change that comparison. This is the single most common misunderstanding about combining these two strategies, and it is the reason a straight-across exchange can produce a study with very little to work on.
The exact annual computation on the exchanged basis depends on your relinquished property's schedule, its remaining period and the convention that applied to it. That arithmetic belongs to whoever prepares your return, and it is worth asking them to show you the number before you commission anything.
Does bonus depreciation apply to a 1031 replacement property?
Usually to the new money only. This is the rule that gets stated wrong most often, so here it is directly.
Reg. 1.168(k)-2(g)(5)(iii)(A) splits on how you got the property. If the replacement property "meets the original use requirement ... and all other requirements of section 168(k)," then both "the remaining exchanged basis for the year of replacement and the remaining excess basis, if any," are eligible for bonus. But if the replacement property "meets the used property acquisition requirements," then "only the remaining excess basis for the year of replacement ... is eligible for the additional first year depreciation deduction."
For most investors, that second sentence is the one that applies. You exchanged into an existing building somebody else already used. So the carryover basis gets no bonus, and the excess basis does.
Build new instead and the first sentence applies, and both pieces are in play. Developers and build-to-suit owners should take that seriously, because it is a materially different answer.
On the rate: the One Big Beautiful Bill Act restored bonus depreciation to 100 percent, and IRS Notice 2026-11, the interim guidance on Section 168(k) after that act, tells taxpayers to substitute "100 percent" for the applicable percentage in the regulations for qualified property acquired after January 19, 2025. It also replaces the old September 27, 2017 acquisition date with January 19, 2025. If you want the broader picture of who the restored allowance actually reaches, we covered who can claim bonus depreciation and who only thinks they can.
One caution worth stating plainly. The regulation that allocates bonus between the two basis pieces was written for the earlier version of Section 168(k) and limits itself on its face to replacements before January 1, 2027. Notice 2026-11 swaps the percentage and the acquisition date but does not revisit the like-kind exchange paragraph. The allocation rule still reads the way it reads, and it still turns on the used property acquisition requirement rather than on any date. Even so, this is an area where guidance may continue to move, so confirm the current state of it with your tax professional rather than taking a date off an article.
Should you make the election to start the whole thing over?
Sometimes, and almost never casually. Model it first.
There is a way out of the two-bucket regime. Reg. 1.168(i)-6(i)(1) lets a taxpayer "elect not to apply this section for any MACRS property involved in a like-kind exchange." Make it, and "the sum of the exchanged basis and excess basis, if any, in the replacement MACRS property is treated as property placed in service by the taxpayer at the time of replacement." One property, one placed in service date, one fresh schedule.
That sounds like the obvious move. It is not, for three reasons.
First, it does not get you bonus depreciation on the carryover piece. The reg is explicit on this. It lists paragraph (h), the additional first year depreciation deduction, among the paragraphs that "apply to property to which this paragraph (i)(1) applies," and paragraph (h) sends you right back to the used property test in Reg. 1.168(k)-2(g)(5). Electing out changes when the clock starts. It does not change which dollars qualify for bonus.
Second, it restarts the long clock on the building. Carryover basis that was 11 years into a 27.5-year schedule goes back to year one. Short-life components inside that basis get accelerated, which helps, but the structural piece gets stretched back out, which hurts. Whether the trade is worth it depends on how much of the basis the components represent and how long you plan to hold.
Third, it is hard to undo. The election has to be made "by the due date (including extensions) of the taxpayer's Federal tax return for the year of replacement," it is made on Form 4562, and once made it "may be revoked only with the consent of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue," which "will be granted only in extraordinary circumstances." That is not a box to tick and reconsider next spring.
It also does not change your gain deferral. The reg says the election "does not affect the application of sections 1031 and 1033," and separately that it "does not affect the application of sections 1245 and 1250 to the relinquished MACRS property." The depreciation treatment moves. The exchange itself does not.
When is a study worth it after an exchange, and when is it not?
Follow the new money. That is the test.
Here is an illustrative deal, not a projection for any specific building. You exchange out of a rental carrying $400,000 of adjusted depreciable basis and into a replacement property, putting in $500,000 of new cash and debt beyond the position that rolled over.
- Exchanged basis, $400,000. Continues on the relinquished property's schedule under Reg. 1.168(i)-6(c). No bonus, assuming you bought used. A study cannot accelerate it.
- Excess basis, $500,000. Treated as placed in service this year. Suppose an engineering-based study properly assigns 25 percent of it, $125,000, to 5, 7 and 15-year components. That $125,000 is eligible for the 100 percent allowance in year one, and the remaining $375,000 starts its own 27.5 or 39-year schedule.
Without the study, that same $500,000 sits on the long line and gives you a few thousand dollars a year. With it, a meaningful slice lands in year one. Those percentages are illustrative; the real split comes out of the actual building and varies enormously by property type and condition.
Now flip the facts. Exchange into something priced close to what you sold, with almost no new money in the deal, and your excess basis is small or zero. There is nothing new to carve up, the carryover basis is off limits, and a study on that property has very little to accelerate. A straight answer is better than a hopeful one here, and the answer on that deal is often no.
Which is also why the fee has to be weighed against the benefit on the specific property rather than on the strategy in general. We broke down what these studies cost and how to tell whether one pays for itself, and the math in that piece is exactly the math to run before you commission anything on a replacement property.
One more thing on the study itself. It has to be engineering-based to be worth paying for, and that holds with more force here, not less, because the whole exercise depends on correctly separating two pools of basis and classifying components inside one of them. A desktop estimate built from square footage and rules of thumb does not do that work. We showed what an engineering-based study actually looks like, and the short version is that the site visit happens in person, by a trained professional, in the building. There is no remote version that produces the same defensible record.
What about the recapture you deferred?
It came with you. The exchange postponed it, and accelerating more depreciation on the new building adds to the pile.
This is not a reason to skip the strategy. It is a reason to know the exit before you pick the entry. Deferral is valuable on its own, and a long hold plus a step-up in basis at death can turn deferral into something permanent. But a sale down the road brings the whole accumulated position back into view, and the number is bigger after a study than before one.
We went through how that works on a straight sale in what happens when you sell a property after cost segregation, including how recapture gets computed and the three ways to soften it. How Sections 1245 and 1250 interact with an exchange specifically is more technical than this article goes, and it belongs in a conversation with whoever prepares your return.
If the exchange itself is the part you are still working out, our guide to the 1031 exchange covers the timelines, the qualified intermediary role and the identification rules, and the episode with Dave Foster on 1031 strategy is worth an hour if you are planning one. CSSI has also published a technical walkthrough of how the basis splits on a replacement property that goes deeper on the regulation than this piece does.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you do a cost segregation study on a property acquired in a 1031 exchange?
Yes. The study is applied to the excess basis, meaning the new money you put into the replacement property beyond the basis that carried over. Reg. 1.168(i)-6(d)(1)(i) treats that excess basis as property placed in service in the year of replacement, which is what opens it to component classification and bonus depreciation. The carryover portion stays on the relinquished property's schedule and a study cannot accelerate it.
Does the exchanged basis qualify for bonus depreciation?
Generally not, if you exchanged into a building somebody else already used. Reg. 1.168(k)-2(g)(5)(iii)(A) says that when the replacement property meets the used property acquisition requirements, only the remaining excess basis is eligible for the additional first year depreciation deduction. If the replacement property instead meets the original use requirement, which typically means you built it, both the exchanged basis and the excess basis can qualify.
What is the difference between exchanged basis and excess basis?
Exchanged basis is the adjusted basis that rolled over from the property you gave up. Excess basis is everything above that, which the regulation defines as any excess of the basis in the replacement property determined under Section 1031(d) over the exchanged basis. In practice, excess basis is the new cash and net new debt you brought to the trade.
Can I elect to start a new depreciation schedule on the whole replacement property?
Yes. Reg. 1.168(i)-6(i)(1) lets you elect not to apply the like-kind exchange depreciation rules, which treats the sum of the exchanged basis and excess basis as placed in service at the time of replacement. It must be made by the due date including extensions of your return for the year of replacement, it is made on Form 4562, and it may be revoked only with the consent of the Commissioner. It does not make the carryover basis eligible for bonus depreciation, and it restarts the building's long recovery period, so model both effects before electing.
Is a cost segregation study worth it if I traded straight across?
Often not. If the replacement property cost about what you sold for, there is little or no excess basis, and the excess basis is the only part a study can accelerate. The more new cash and debt you put into the trade, the more a study has to work with. That is the first thing to check, and it can be checked before you spend anything.
Where to go from here
If you have completed an exchange, or you are planning one and want to know what the depreciation picture looks like on the other side, the question worth answering is whether a study produces more than it costs on your specific facts. On a replacement property, that comes down almost entirely to how much excess basis the deal created.
I offer a no-cost analysis, delivered through my relationship with CSSI (Cost Segregation Services, Inc.). Want to know whether a study would even pay for itself on your replacement property? That is what the no-cost analysis is for. No obligation and no pitch. If the numbers say it will not pay for itself, I will tell you, which is the whole reason the analysis is worth your time. You do not need to gather documents first. Bring the address and the rough facts of the trade.
- Book a time: https://calendly.com/david-wiener/cs
- Or call 770-224-8504, option two.
If you want to see the scope and process before you talk to anyone, the cost segregation page at davidhwiener.com lays it out.
This article is educational and is not tax advice. Depreciation and like-kind exchange rules turn on facts specific to your property, your entity and your return, and tax law changes. Talk to your own CPA or tax professional before acting on anything here.